Gardeners Soap is so popular they sometimes can't quite keep up with production. I don't think it is the soap though, I think it is the idea of the soap. They got tired of making so much of this soap using ground cinnamon and cinnamon and clove essential oils that they finally changed the recipe to something else and it still sold! They didn't like that one too much and changed it again and it still sold! So now they have several different Gardener's Soaps. Which one would you like? Well, you get which ever one we happen to have in stock. We know you won't care as long as it has the cute picture on it!